| Date | Home | Time/Results | Away | League | Season | Ground | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Borrowash Victoria  | 0 - 3 |  Mickleover F.C. | Friendly | 2023/24 | Anderson Electrical Arena | Report | |
| Mickleover F.C. | 0 - 1 |  Burton Albion | Friendly | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Report | |
| Mickleover F.C. | 5 - 0 |  Belper United | Friendly | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Report | |
Buxton  | 6 - 1 | Mickleover F.C. | Friendly | 2023/24 | The Silverlands | Report | |
Ilkeston Town  | 1 - 1 | Mickleover F.C. | Friendly | 2023/24 | New Manor Ground | Report | |
| Mickleover F.C. | 3 - 1 | Stapleford Town | Friendly | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Report | |
Alfreton Town  | 2 - 0 | Mickleover F.C. | Friendly | 2023/24 | Impact Arena | Report | |
St Ives Town  | 0 - 2 | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | St Ives Town Football Club | Report | |
| Mickleover F.C. | 4 - 0 |  Berkhamsted | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Report | |
| Mickleover F.C. | 4 - 2 |  Alvechurch | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Report | |
Leamington  | 0 - 1 | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | The Phillips 66 Community Stadium | Report | |
| Mickleover F.C. | 2 - 1 |  Hitchin Town | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Report | |
Long Eaton United  | 0 - 5 | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Grange Park | Report | |
| Mickleover F.C. | 3 - 0 | Ilkeston Town | The Emirates FA Cup | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Report | |
| Mickleover F.C. | 5 - 0 |  Leiston | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Report | |
AFC Telford United  | 1 - 2 | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | New Bucks Head | Report | |
| Mickleover F.C. | 3 - 1 |  Spalding United | The Emirates FA Cup | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Report | |
| Mickleover F.C. | 5 - 0 |  AFC Sudbury | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Report | |
Barwell  | 1 - 2 | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Kirkby Road | Report | |
Bromsgrove Sporting  | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Report | |||
Stourbridge  | 2 - 0 | Mickleover F.C. | The Emirates FA Cup | 2023/24 | War Memorial Athletic Ground | Report | |
| Barwell | 2 - 2 | Mickleover F.C. | The FA Trophy | 2023/24 | Kirkby Road | Report | |
| Mickleover F.C. | 2 - 0 |  Royston Town | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Report | |
| Bromsgrove Sporting | 1 - 1 | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Report | ||
| Mickleover F.C. | 2 - 2 |  Redditch United | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Report | |
| Mickleover F.C. | Stourbridge | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Report | ||
Worksop Town  | 0 - 5 | Mickleover F.C. | The FA Trophy | 2023/24 | Sandy Lane | Report | |
Stratford Town  | 3 - 2 | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Knights Lane | Report | |
| Mickleover F.C. | 1 - 1 |  Needham Market | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Report | |
Spennymoor Town  | 1 - 3 | Mickleover F.C. | The FA Trophy | 2023/24 | The Brewery Field | Report | |
Stamford  | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Zeeco Stadium | Report | ||
Kettering Town  | 2 - 0 | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Report | ||
| Mickleover F.C. | 2 - 0 |  Nuneaton Borough | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Report | |
Halesowen Town  | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | The Grove | Preview | ||
| Mickleover F.C. |  Belper Town | DCFA Senior Challenge Cup | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Preview | ||
Oldham Athletic  | Mickleover F.C. | The FA Trophy | 2023/24 | Boundary Park | Preview | ||
| Leiston | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Preview | |||
| Mickleover F.C. | Leamington | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Preview | ||
| Hitchin Town | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Top Field | Preview | ||
| Mickleover F.C. | Long Eaton United | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Preview | ||
Coalville Town  | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Owen Street Sports Ground | Preview | ||
| Mickleover F.C. | AFC Telford United | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Preview | ||
| Mickleover F.C. | Stourbridge | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Preview | ||
| Berkhamsted | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Preview | |||
| Mickleover F.C. | St Ives Town | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Preview | ||
| Mickleover F.C. | Barwell | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Preview | ||
| AFC Sudbury | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Preview | |||
| Mickleover F.C. | Bromsgrove Sporting | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Preview | ||
| Royston Town | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Preview | |||
| Mickleover F.C. | Kettering Town | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Preview | ||
| Redditch United | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | The Valley Stadium | Preview | ||
| Mickleover F.C. | Halesowen Town | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Preview | ||
| Nuneaton Borough | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Preview | |||
| Alvechurch | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Alvechurch Football Club | Preview | ||
| Mickleover F.C. | Coalville Town | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Preview | ||
| Stourbridge | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | War Memorial Athletic Ground | Preview | ||
| Mickleover F.C. | Stratford Town | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Preview | ||
| Needham Market | Mickleover F.C. | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Needham Market Football Club | Preview | ||
| Mickleover F.C. | Stamford | Southern League Premier Central | 2023/24 | Don Amott Arena | Preview |
